A Navy Captain goes missing while driving late at night and is eventually found dead in a cabin with the team suspecting that his murder may be espionage-related but everything changes when they uncover a clue which has the team believing that the officer's life might be a motive for his death...
Late at night, a single car drives on a lone stretch of road as the Everly Brothers - Bye Bye plays in the background.
Inside the car, Navy Captain Thomas Jennings is singing along to the song but is left startled when he hears a loud thump with Jennings realizing he may hit something.
Jennings then stops the car, unbuckles his seatbelt and gets out.
As he steps out into the night, he uses a flashlight, remarking "Oh, no" upon seeing someone lying in the distance.
Jennings runs forward and reaches the person, stating "Oh, my God", obviously horrified at what he's done.
He then turns the body over, only to find that it's fake with a pillow.
Jennings mutters, "What the Hell?" before throwing it aside, disgusted.
"Anyone there?", Jennings calls.
But there's no reply.
Jennings then gets back to the car and gets inside but finds the keys are missing which means that Jennings has been left completely stranded.
"What the Hell's going on here?", Jennings remarks, stunned.
Jennings then gets out of the car again while wondering where his keys are.
It then cuts to show that someone is watching Jennings from the bushes.
Jennings eventually gives up searching and attempts to use his cell phone, only to find that there's no signal available. He slips the phone back into his pocket.
Jennings continues searching with the sound of leaves rustling startling him.
"Anyone there?", Jennings calls, his flashlight scanning the area.
In the bushes, it's shown that the same person is still there, keeping an eye on Jennings.
At the car, Jennings is still examining the area, calling "Hello?", obviously hoping for an answer but yet again, he gets no reply whatsoever.
It then cuts to the same person presumably approaching Jennings with Jennings being left startled when he turns around to meet the unidentified person seconds later.
The area around the warehouse is now a crime scene and Tony tells Gibbs that the victim is twenty year old Brandon Skyes who has a rap sheet and was even suspected of causing a homicide over an iPod.
- Beary Smiles's voice is provided by Michael Weatherly who plays Anthony DiNozzo Junior on the show.
- Beary Smiles is clearly based on the real-life Teddy Ruxpin toy, a talking animatronic bear introduced in 1985.
|Leroy Jethro Gibbs||Mark Harmon||NCIS Special Agent in charge of the NCIS Major Case Response Team.|
|Anthony DiNozzo Junior||Michael Weatherly||Senior Special Agent and second-in-command of the NCIS Major Case Response Team.|
|Ziva David||Cote de Pablo||Mossad/NCIS Liaison Officer and a member of the NCIS Major Case Response Team.|
|Timothy McGee||Sean Murray (actor)||Junior Special Agent of the NCIS Major Case Response team.|
|Abigail Sciuto||Pauley Perrette||Forensic Specialist associated with the NCIS Major Case Response Team.|
|Leon Vance||Rocky Carroll||Director of NCIS.|
|Donald Mallard||David McCallum||Chief Medical Examiner associated with the NCIS Major Case Response Team.|
|James Palmer||Brian Dietzen||Assistant Medical Examiner.|
|Kevin Nelson||Chris Carmack||Rebecca Jennings's fiance and also Captain Thomas Jennings and Brandon Sykes's killer.|
|Rebecca Jennings||Christine Woods||Daughter of the victim.|
|Adrianna Lopez||Eva Tamargo||Cuban woman and Captain Jennings's girlfriend who came to America to pose to be his maid.|
|Jessica Shore||Danneel Harris||Lab Assistant working with the victim and Fiancee of Brandon Sykes.|
|Rod Daniels||James Urbaniak||Scientist and Project Supervisor as well as a Doctor.|
|Thomas Jennings||Michael Toland||Captain in the United States Navy and the main murder victim.|
|Lee Chandler||David Pease||Sheriff who was first on the scene when the Captain's body was found in a warming hut.|
|Brandon Sykes||Cole David||Petty Thief who was engaged to Jessica Shore. Later got into a fight with Kevin Nelson who killed him by throwing him off the roof just as Gibbs and the team were approaching the warehouse.|